Modern man talks of a battle with Nature, forgetting that, if we won the battle, he would find himself on the losing side".E. F. SCHUMACHER
Can we distill our present global predicament into a contest between the "connected" and the "unconnected"?
What made me ponder on this was watching the excellent documentary film on Rosia Montana http://www.rosiamontana-thefilm.com/ which highlights the contrasting values on one side, of the locals who don't want to move away from their homes and on the other side, of the "investors" who see no problem with making money from mining the earth of its riches. This village in Romania is being torn apart by the conflict between those living a very modest life in harmony with their natural environment, and those wanting to extract the buried gold using a process invoving opencast mining and cyanide extraction.
To my mind, this scenario represents, on a small scale what is being played out across the planet, with globalisation and the McDonaldisation of cultures and societies. Often, the conflicting parties are defined as the clever, progressives versus the uneducated, unsophisticated traditionalists. And, in this film, the contrast is stark- the peasants with a few sheep and cows, living a subsistence life with few luxuries are up against the rich and powerful Canadian-funded corporation.
But there is a common thread to be detected here- people who have found connection with their environment cannot contemplate damaging their beloved earth any more than they could hurt their own children. The disconnected, having lost that earth-ing have no such qualms and any rape, mutilation or other destrcution of the planet can be justified in the name of profit or perhaps what they perceive as "progress". If we extend this idea to its logical conclusion of course, we shouldn't be mining coal or other precious materials which have delivered us a wealth of material benefits, albeit at a cost.
However, in this film, Rosia Montana, one resident of the village tells us that their forebears believed that the earth had spirits who could guide them to its riches under the surface but that misfortune would befall them if they were greedy or otherwise exceeded their needs. And in this village, gold mining had a history going back 2000 years to pre-Roman times. One might conclude therefore that minerals such as gold have a legitimate purpose for humans, but certain guidelines should limit our use of them or the price we will pay for our greed will ultimately exceed any benefit we derived from it.
Such a principle would seem to have guided many "primitive" cultures in the past, whether it refered to the mining of gold or the killing of animals for food, and as long as we are "connected" , those groundrules will provide us with the boundaries beyond which we should not venture.